Bills-Broncos Controversy: How Pass Interference Calls Are Deciding NFL Playoff Games

Saturday night's AFC divisional round game between the Buffalo Bills and Denver Broncos ended in heartbreak—not with a touchdown, but with flags. Two defensive pass interference penalties in overtime handed Denver 47 yards on their game-winning drive, capping a 33-30 victory that left players, coaches, and fans questioning whether officials decided the outcome more than the athletes themselves.

The controversy began when Bills wide receiver Brandin Cooks appeared to catch a pass before Broncos cornerback Ja'Quan McMillian wrestled the ball away. Officials ruled it an interception. Bills coach Sean McDermott was emphatic: "That play is not even close. That's a catch all the way."

What followed was worse. On Denver's ensuing drive, the Bills were flagged twice for defensive pass interference—first on Taron Johnson, then on Tre'Davious White. The penalties marked only the second instance in 25 years where a team committed multiple pass interference calls on a single overtime drive. White, the former LSU All-American, didn't mince words: "Referees just don't know ball, man."

His frustration captures a broader tension that's been simmering in the NFL for years: Have pass interference rules tilted too far in favor of offenses? And are game-changing penalties being called on plays that, a generation ago, would have been considered clean football?

The Evolution of Pass Interference: From Physicality to Penalties

In the 1970s, defensive backs routinely manhandled receivers throughout their routes. That changed dramatically in 1978 when the NFL instituted the "illegal contact" rule, restricting defenders from making contact with receivers more than five yards downfield. The rule opened up the passing game, but also began a decades-long pendulum swing toward offense.

In 2004, the league doubled down, emphasizing stricter enforcement of existing pass interference rules. Passing numbers exploded, and defense became increasingly difficult. Today, defensive pass interference in the NFL is a spot foul with an automatic first down—potentially worth 40, 50, even 60 yards. College football caps the penalty at 15 yards, recognizing the game-altering impact.

The 2019 season saw an attempt at reform when the NFL allowed coaches to challenge pass interference calls. But officials were reluctant to overturn calls, and the process slowed games. The league abandoned the experiment after one year, leaving judgment entirely to on-field officials in real time.

The College-to-Pro Adjustment: Learning a Different Game

For defensive backs making the jump from college football to the NFL, pass interference rules represent one of the steepest learning curves in the sport. What earned you All-American honors at Alabama or LSU might earn you a crucial 30-yard penalty on Sundays.

The differences are substantial. In college, defenders can maintain contact with receivers as long as the receiver is in front of them. The 15-yard maximum penalty means defenses sometimes intentionally commit pass interference to prevent touchdowns—a calculated risk that makes tactical sense. In the NFL, that same calculation changes dramatically when the penalty could be 50 yards.

McMillian's journey illustrates this adjustment. The East Carolina standout went undrafted in 2022 despite being a Jim Thorpe Award semifinalist and second-team All-American. At 5'10" and 183 pounds, scouts questioned whether he could transition his aggressive, physical style to the NFL's more restrictive contact rules.

Three years later, McMillian has become one of Denver's most valuable defensive backs, mastering the delicate balance between physicality and penalty avoidance. His overtime interception against the Bills—ripping the ball from Cooks' hands—showcased the kind of aggressive play that college coaches taught him. The controversy was whether the play crossed the line into a penalty.

White's path offers another perspective. Drafted 27th overall by Buffalo in 2017 after a stellar career at LSU, White quickly became one of the league's elite cornerbacks, earning first-team All-Pro honors in 2019. But even veteran defensive backs talk about the constant adjustment required. "You're taught to play through the receiver's hands in college," White explained after the game. "That's fundamental cornerback technique. But in the NFL, if you do that and the receiver sells it, you're getting flagged."

The learning curve extends beyond the rulebook. NFL receivers are better at drawing penalties, understanding how to position their bodies to make contact look worse than it is. Quarterbacks throw "shot plays" specifically designed to draw pass interference. The college game doesn't prepare defensive backs for this level of gamesmanship.

When Penalties Decide Playoff Games

The Bills-Broncos game is far from an isolated incident. Pass interference calls have decided multiple crucial games this season, raising questions about whether the penalty has become too powerful a weapon.

In December, the Detroit Lions were called for two offensive pass interference penalties in the final 30 seconds against the Pittsburgh Steelers, including one on the game's final play that negated what would have been a miracle touchdown. According to the Elias Sports Bureau, Detroit became the only team in 30 years to have two offensive pass interference penalties enforced in the final 30 seconds of regulation.

Former NFL players have noticed the trend. Three-time Defensive Player of the Year J.J. Watt tweeted about the Bills-Broncos game: "Weak pass interference call." Dallas Cowboys star Micah Parsons added: "Man I hate when games is won like that!"

The criticism extends beyond players. ESPN analyst Dan Orlovsky called the officiating "absolutely atrocious," noting that 53 yards in penalties on an overtime drive "is just bad officiating." When prominent analysts, former players, and coaches all express similar concerns, it suggests the issue transcends any single controversial call.

The statistics reveal how unusual Saturday's penalties were. Buffalo had been one of the league's most disciplined defenses all season, tied for the fewest defensive pass interference penalties. For them to commit two in a single overtime drive defied both their season-long trends and historical precedent.

The Broader Impact: Defense in Handcuffs?

Critics argue that modern pass interference enforcement has fundamentally altered football's competitive balance. Defenses play tentative, afraid that one mistimed hand placement will gift the offense 40 yards. This hesitancy makes it easier for offenses to succeed, contributing to record-breaking passing numbers and high-scoring games.

The data supports this concern. Offensive pass interference is called far less frequently than defensive pass interference. In 2024, the average team was called for just 1.2 offensive pass interference penalties—nearly one-tenth the rate of defensive penalties.

For young cornerbacks entering the league, the adjustment can be career-altering. Scouts now look for defensive backs who can avoid contact, rather than the physical, press-coverage corners who dominated previous eras. The premium on avoiding penalties sometimes outweighs the value of actually preventing completions.

Looking Ahead: Can Balance Be Restored?

The Bills-Broncos controversy reignites debates about balancing offense and defense. Should the NFL adopt college football's 15-yard cap on pass interference? Should there be different standards for playoff games? Should officials be held more accountable?

These questions have no easy answers. The NFL's entertainment value derives from explosive passing attacks and high-scoring games. But there's also value in competitive games decided by players rather than penalties. Saturday night featured two teams trading big plays for nearly four quarters, only to end with officials' flags determining the outcome.

For defensive backs like White and McMillian, the frustration is personal. They've dedicated their lives to mastering their craft, only to see games hinge on judgment calls that seem inconsistent. "The game is fought so hard and comes down to the wire," White said. "It should be up to the players to decide the game."

As the playoffs continue, expect more controversial calls and continued debate. The league has created a system where pass interference can be more impactful than most touchdowns. For now, defensive backs will continue walking the tightrope between aggressive coverage and costly penalties, knowing that one wrong move can end their season.

---

Sources

1. Getzenberg, Alaina. "Bills miffed by officials' ruling on pivotal INT in OT loss." ESPN, January 18, 2026. https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/47648109/bills-miffed-officials-ruling-pivotal-int-ot-loss
2. Seifert, Kevin. "Key questions about close officiating calls in the Broncos' win over the Bills." ESPN, January 18, 2026. https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/47645805/playoffs-divisional-round-denver-broncos-buffalo-bills-officiating-pass-interference
3. "Tre White blames officials for critical call during Bills' playoff loss to Broncos." Sports Illustrated, January 18, 2026. https://www.si.com/nfl/bills/onsi/tre-white-blames-refs-for-critical-bad-judgement-call-in-bills-loss-to-broncos-divisional-round
4. "Evolution of the NFL Rules." NFL Football Operations. https://operations.nfl.com/the-rules/evolution-of-the-nfl-rules/
5. "Pass interference." Wikipedia. Accessed January 19, 2026. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pass_interference
6. "NFL pass interference rules, explained." Yahoo Sports, September 4, 2025. https://sports.yahoo.com/article/nfl-pass-interference-rules-explained-100001135.html
7. "College football pass interference rule, explained." FanSided, September 4, 2021. https://fansided.com/2021/09/04/college-football-pass-interference-rule-explained/
8. "Ja'Quan McMillian." Wikipedia. Accessed January 19, 2026. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ja'Quan_McMillian
9. "Tre'Davious White." Wikipedia. Accessed January 19, 2026. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tre'Davious_White
10. "Controversial calls against Bills leave fans livid following OT loss to Broncos." Yahoo Sports, January 18, 2026. https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/controversial-calls-against-bills-leave-023448393.html