The Record-Setter Hits a Wall
Jacob Misiorowski has spent most of 2026 making MLB hitters look foolish. The Crowder College product and Milwaukee Brewers ace is on pace to set a new MLB record for the lowest batting average allowed by a pitcher — a mark that, by some accounts, would be more meaningful than a Cy Young Award. He has also thrown more 100+ mph pitches than 15 entire MLB franchises have combined since 2008, a stat so absurd it prompted a minor media firestorm when it surfaced this week.
Then came the Cubs.
On Wednesday, September 2, Misiorowski lasted just four innings against Chicago, allowing five earned runs — his worst outing of the season by a considerable margin. He struck out five and Milwaukee still won 9-5, but the performance set off alarm bells. Misiorowski said afterward he "didn't feel great" but "had to make it work." The Brewers' bats bailed him out; the question now is whether they'll keep needing to.
The Shutdown Debate
The rough start didn't happen in a vacuum. Fatigue has been the word hovering over Misiorowski's second half, and the Cubs outing gave it a louder megaphone. A former Cy Young Award winner publicly called on the Brewers to shut Misiorowski down or limit his starts heading into the postseason, arguing Milwaukee's surrounding roster is capable enough to carry the load. It's a reasonable ask — protecting a pitcher of Misiorowski's caliber for October matters more than any regular-season win.
A Hall of Famer also sent Misiorowski an encouraging message before the Cubs start, urging him to trust his stuff. He threw hard. The results just didn't follow.
The tension is real: Misiorowski is the best pitcher in the National League by multiple measures, but a diminished version of him in a playoff series is potentially worse than a rested version who missed two late-season turns. The Brewers' front office hasn't publicly committed to any plan, but the conversation is happening.
Ashby Stays Steady in the Bullpen
While Misiorowski commands the headlines, fellow Crowder alum Aaron Ashby quietly had a workmanlike week out of the Brewers' bullpen. He appeared in four games between September 1 and September 5, tossing one inning in each outing. He struck out two in a September 4 appearance without allowing a run, then gave up one earned run the following day — leaving his ERA sitting at 3.19. Nothing flashy, but exactly the kind of reliable late-inning work a playoff-caliber team needs from its depth arms.
The Bigger Picture
Two pitchers from a junior college in Neosho, Missouri, are contributing to a Brewers team with genuine World Series aspirations. That alone is a story. But the week belonged to Misiorowski — not because of what he did on the mound Wednesday, but because of what his season represents and what's now at stake.
The record books are within reach. So is October. The Brewers just have to get him there in one piece.
AI-generated summary

