McPherson Kicks Bengals Into the History Books
Evan McPherson didn't just make field goals in Cincinnati's Week 1 win over Tampa Bay — he made history. The former Florida Gator went a perfect 4-for-4 on field goal attempts as the Bengals held off the Buccaneers 33-27, and the performance was good enough to earn him his fifth AFC Special Teams Player of the Week award. Bengals head coach Zac Taylor called him "the best kicker in the league" after the game, and the hardware suggests the rest of the NFL agrees. McPherson has now collected more AFC Special Teams Player of the Week honors than any kicker in Bengals franchise history.
It's a clean, emphatic opening statement from a player who's made clutch kicking his calling card since arriving in Cincinnati out of Gainesville.
Anzalone's Rough Night in Tampa
The same game that cemented McPherson's legend was one to forget for fellow Gator Alex Anzalone. The veteran linebacker, now in Tampa Bay's colors after signing with the Buccaneers in the offseason, turned in the team's lowest-graded performance of the night. Per PFF, Anzalone missed two tackles and surrendered multiple chunk plays in coverage, finishing with a 32.3 overall grade. Head coach Todd Bowles publicly backed his veteran, but a 36 run-defense grade is a tough number to defend heading into Week 2.
Around the League
Elsewhere, the Gator pipeline produced a mixed Week 1 bag:
Malik Davis won't be a factor for the Cowboys the rest of the season. The running back underwent hip surgery after suffering a serious injury in practice, landing on injured reserve and forcing Dallas to scramble for backfield depth before their Week 2 matchup with the Giants.
Kaiir Elam's time with the Chargers is over before it really started. Los Angeles cut ties with the former first-round cornerback just days after the season opener, releasing him from the practice squad. Elam, selected 23rd overall in the 2022 draft, never found a foothold in the league after being traded out of Buffalo.
Austin Barber had the kind of debut that turns into a career. The rookie offensive lineman impressed Cleveland's coaching staff enough in the Browns' Week 1 loss to the Jaguars that he locked down his starting spot on the offensive line going forward — a rare bright spot in a difficult day for Cleveland.
Kyle Pitts is still searching for his 2026 footing. The Falcons tight end was targeted just once in Atlanta's 13-20 loss to Pittsburgh and failed to record a reception, leaving fantasy managers and Gator faithful alike frustrated heading into Week 2.
Jonathan Greenard was ruled out for the Eagles' Week 2 game against Tennessee, continuing an injury-hampered stretch for the edge rusher, who also missed time in the lead-up to the opener.
Anthony Richardson avoided a serious scare after missing practice Tuesday with a weightlifting injury, and remained on track to serve as the Colts' QB2 behind starter Daniel Jones for their Week 2 matchup.
It's early, but the McPherson story is the one worth bookmarking. If Week 1 is any indication, the Bengals' kicker isn't just the most reliable Gator in the NFL — he might be the most reliable kicker in it, full stop.
AI-generated summary














