Joe Fagnano didn't earn his first NFL start — he inherited it from a disaster.
By the time the Baltimore Ravens named the undrafted UConn rookie their Week 9 starter against the Jacksonville Jaguars, it had already been the kind of quarterback carousel that makes front offices lose sleep. Lamar Jackson, who had missed three games with an ankle sprain, tore up his thumb on his first snap back in Week 8 against the Bills — the same game in which backup Tyler Huntley went down with turf toe severe enough to end his season. Both were subsequently placed on injured reserve.
That left Fagnano, a 24-year-old who walked on at Maine before transferring to UConn and spent seven years in college football before going undrafted, as Baltimore's most experienced healthy quarterback. That sentence alone tells you everything about the Ravens' Week 9 situation.
The Backstory
Fagnano didn't come out of nowhere, exactly — he had already seen action in Baltimore's Week 8 loss to Buffalo, throwing for 91 yards with one interception after Huntley was hurt. But a Thursday Night Football start, on a short week, against a Jaguars defense with nothing to lose, is a different animal entirely.
His former college coach had no doubts. "I always felt like he was going to have a chance," he told Sports Illustrated — a quote that reads equally as faith and prophecy.
Baltimore scrambled for insurance in the days before kickoff, signing Austin Reed to serve as backup and working out Kedon Slovis amid concerns that Fagnano was also managing an ankle injury of his own. He practiced Tuesday with a brace on his right ankle. He started Thursday anyway.
The Game
It did not go well. Fagnano completed passes for just 60 yards and threw two interceptions in a 33-10 blowout loss, with the Ravens' offense never finding any rhythm against a Jacksonville club that showed up as double-digit road favorites for good reason. Fagnano added 13 yards on the ground, but the box score was a secondary concern to the broader portrait of a franchise in freefall at the game's most important position.
The Ravens have since moved to stabilize things, trading for veteran Jacoby Brissett from the Cardinals — a signal that Baltimore, whatever it thinks of Fagnano long-term, isn't counting on a walk-on rookie to salvage a season that was already wobbling before Jackson's thumb gave out.
The Bigger Picture
Fagnano's two-game stretch — 151 combined passing yards, three interceptions, two losses — won't earn him a Pro Bowl nod. But context matters. He is an undrafted free agent who went from practice squad depth piece to the starting lineup of an NFL team within the same season, against two legitimate defenses, while his own team was in organizational crisis mode.
Fellow UConn alum Travis Jones, the Ravens' defensive tackle, was also in uniform for both losses but did not register notable individual stats in either game. With the Ravens trading for Brissett, Fagnano's moment in the starting spotlight appears to be over — but for a player who spent seven years grinding through college football just to get here, the experience itself is the milestone.
AI-generated summary